A Guide to the 12 Best Cupcakes in NYC – Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth

New York City is known for its foodie culture, and cupcakes are a staple pastry that should not be missed.

Whether you’re on the go, in a park, or sitting in a cozy cafe, a cupcake is a perfect addition to your day.

To help you discover the best cupcakes in the city, we have put together a list of the top cupcake bakers in New York City.

From iconic bakeries with worldwide recognition to up-and-coming spots that you’ll want to keep to yourself, there’s something for every cupcake lover in NYC.

1. Little Cupcake Bakeshop

  • Website
  • Address: 30 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
  • Phone: (212) 941-9100


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Little Cupcake Bakeshop (@littlecupcakebakeshop)

Little Cupcake Bakeshop is a cute and charming bakery that specializes in baking wholesome traditional American desserts using the freshest, sustainable ingredients.

They source their ingredients predominantly from local farms in the surrounding areas and all of their baking is done in small batches on-site.

The bakery is well-known for its Brooklyn Blackout Cake, Mott Street cupcake, and Blue Velvet Cake.

With the friendly and helpful staff, you can enjoy the quality and flavor of their desserts.

Although the religious decor seems out of place, you will love the bakery’s ambiance for being clean and stylish.

The prices are higher compared to other bakeries, but it is worth the cost.

2. Molly’s Cupcakes

  • Website
  • Address: 228 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
  • Phone: (212) 414-2253

Mollys Cupcakes

Molly’s Cupcakes in New York City is a neighborhood spot known for its cupcakes that strike a balance between indulgence and restraint.

The clean and brightly lit cafe space offers ample seating, including a counter bar and several tables and window seats.

Their cupcakes are baked from scratch in small batches throughout the day using the finest and freshest ingredients, and there is a wide range of flavors to choose from, including classic and unique options, as well as center-filled and vegan cupcakes.

I recommend trying the famous center-filled cupcakes, like Cake Batter and Creme Brûlée.

You can also create your own cupcakes by choosing a cake flavor, frosting, and toppings.

3. Funny Face Bakery

  • Website
  • Address: 6 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038
  • Phone: (212) 480-4004


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Funny Face Bakery (@funnyfacebakery)

Funny Face Bakery is a creative and impressive cupcake shop known for its fresh and flavorful cupcakes, cookies, and banana bread.

I would recommend the strawberry banana cupcake and chocolate chip cookie.

The shop is praised for its moist, delicious cakes, which are paired with icing that is not too sweet.

The vintage decor adds to the cozy and welcoming ambiance of the bakery.

You will enjoy their cupcakes and cookies, as well as their nationwide shipping, which is quick and not too expensive.

The owner is known for her kindness and a special force of love, making Funny Face Bakery a favorite among many.

4. Magnolia Bakery – Moynihan Train Hall

  • Website
  • Address: 383 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
  • Phone: (646) 908-3500


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Magnolia Bakery (@magnoliabakery)

Magnolia Bakery – Moynihan Train Hall in Manhattan is a go-to destination for cakes with pure, creamy frosting and light, pillowy cakes with fine crumbs.

It was established in 1996 on a quaint, cobblestone corner in the West Village.

I would recommend the vanilla cupcakes with confetti sprinkles, also don’t forget to try their banana pudding with cake and banana chunks.

Its sweet smell of cakes, cookies, pies, and pudding became a sensation, with its red velvet cupcakes and banana pudding becoming iconic.

Magnolia’s easy, grab-and-go items are perfect for commuters in a hurry.

People from all over the world came to visit Magnolia Bakery, with some even speculating that New York pretzel guys would turn into cupcake guys.

With the success of its neighborhood bakery, Magnolia Bakery has expanded into new neighborhoods, written cookbooks, and helped people celebrate their special moments.

Despite its growth, Magnolia Bakery remains committed to its mission of making every day sweeter than the last, with its doors always open and a dollop of buttercream making everything better.

5. Brooklyn Cupcake

  • Website
  • Address: 335 Union Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
  • Phone: (718) 576-3600

Brooklyn Cupcake is a bakery founded by sisters Carmen Rodriguez and Gina Madera, along with their cousin Michelle Caballero.

The bakery started as a neighborhood spot in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and has grown into NYC’s most celebrated Latino dessert shop.

It offers a wide variety of unique and delicious cupcake flavors, perfect for special occasions or just a sweet treat.

I would recommend the moist and perfectly sweet cupcakes, with flavors such as coquito, flan, tiramisu, and french toast cafecito.

The bakery also offers beautiful wedding cakes and provides excellent communication and delivery services.

Their menu features Puerto Rican and Italian-inspired cupcakes, such as Flan, Dulce de Leche, Tres Leche, Tiramisu, Rainbow Cookie, and Coquito.

Prices are affordable compared to other bakeries.

6. Buttercup Bake Shop

  • Website
  • Address: 167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
  • Phone: (212) 350-4144


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Buttercup Bake Shop (@buttercupbakeshop)

Buttercup Bake Shop is a charming little bakery in Manhattan that offers a variety of delicious and visually appealing cupcakes, cookies, and pastries.

Jennifer Appel, the founder of Buttercup Bake Shop, began her career as a clinical psychologist but found her passion in baking.

In 1996, she opened Magnolia Bakery in Greenwich Village before opening Buttercup Bake Shop on her own in 1999.

The shop offers classic American desserts that have been enjoyed by notable figures such as Martha Stewart, Al Roker, and Senator Hillary Clinton.

You will appreciate the friendly service and the high-quality desserts, although the prices can be a bit steep.

The shop also offers kosher options and mini cupcakes.

Some of the most recommended items include the red velvet and carrot cake cupcakes, the s’mores cupcake, the lemon bar, and the chocolate icing.

Buttercup has received media attention and has been featured on The Today Show, MTV, Fox, and CNN, and in a romantic novel.

7. Butter Lane

  • Website
  • Address: 123 E 7th St, New York, NY 10009
  • Phone: (212) 677-2880


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Butter Lane Bakery (@butterlane)

Butter Lane is a small, cute cupcake shop that offers a wide range of cake and frosting flavors.

The cupcakes are fresh, tasty, and not overly sweet.

You will love the option to choose their cake and frosting separately, with many delicious options to choose from.

The salted caramel with chocolate and the chocolate cupcake with strawberry buttercream are some of the popular flavors.

Butter Lane uses all-natural fruit instead of food coloring in their icing.

The bakery also offers cupcake-making classes, which are a fun activity for both individuals and couples.

8. Sprinkles New York – Upper East Side

  • Website
  • Address: 780 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10065
  • Phone: (212) 207-8375


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Sprinkles (@sprinklescupcakes)

Sprinkles Upper East Side is located in Midtown East and offers pickup and delivery services for customers.

It is a famous bakery that specializes in cupcakes, cookies, layer cakes, and brownies.

The bakery is known for delivering high-quality and delicious baked goods using the finest ingredients.

Their signature cupcakes and treats have been enjoyed by many, and the bakery is considered by some as the best cupcake spot in New York City.

With an iPad ordering system and a friendly staff, Sprinkles offers an excellent experience for anyone looking for a sweet treat.

9. Martha’s Country Bakery


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Martha’s Country Bakery (@marthascountrybakery)

Martha’s Country Bakery is a cozy neighborhood spot that offers a great selection of cakes, cupcakes, and other sweets.

Martha’s Bakery was founded with the aim of providing classic American baked goods in a warm and friendly environment.

All of their treats are made from scratch using the finest ingredients, and they bake everything on-site to fill their stores with the delicious aroma of fresh cakes and pies.

The atmosphere is reminiscent of a dessert restaurant, with a cool vibe and dimmed lights, and on weekends they have a DJ playing in the back.

Additionally, they offer cakes and cupcakes for special occasions such as birthday parties and office meetings.

Their coffee bar is also a favorite among coffee lovers, offering expertly roasted and brewed coffee in a variety of flavors.

10. Baked

  • Website
  • Address: 359 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
  • Phone: (718) 222-0345 ext. 1


Baked is a bakery that offers a wide range of sweet treats including cupcakes, cakes, and unique twists on classic snacks.

It is a bakery founded by Matt Lewis and Renato Poliafito, who share a passion for regional American desserts.

Baked offers a wide selection of desserts, including gluten-free options and a unique twist on old classics.

The prices are reasonable, making Baked a great option for those looking for quality baked goods at an affordable price.

They are highly recommended for wedding cakes, with moist and delicious passion fruit cakes being a popular choice.

In addition to the bakery, Matt and Renato have written cookbooks and created new products.

11. Buttah

  • Website
  • Address: 377 Onderdonk Ave, Ridgewood, NY 11385
  • Phone: (347) 833-7899


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Buttah (@buttah_bakery)

Buttah is a bakery located in Ridgewood, offering a variety of cupcakes, cakes, and desserts.

I would recommend the moist and flavorful cakes, with the Banana Peanut Buttah cupcake being a popular favorite.

The Brooklyn blackout cupcake and the Tres Leches cake are also good choices.

You will appreciate the reasonable prices and attractive presentation of the desserts.

12. Erin McKenna’s Bakery NYC

  • Website
  • Address: 248 Broome St, New York, NY 10002
  • Phone: (855) 462-2292


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Erin McKenna’s Bakery NYC,Baby (@erinmckennasbakery)

Erin McKenna’s Bakery NYC is a Lower East Side bakery that specializes in vegan and gluten-free treats made with natural sweeteners like agave.

Despite being vegan and gluten-free, their cupcakes, cakes, and donuts are all visually appealing and delicious.

The bakery offers a wide variety of treats that are perfect for people with dietary restrictions.

Some of the treats recommended include the carrot with cinnamon sugar cupcake, the gingerbread cupcake, and the raspberry brownie.

Leave a Comment