11 Fun & Exciting Costumes Stores In NYC

If you are used to themed parties and Halloween, you will agree that costume stores are an important aspect of our lives. I mean they add so much fun to our lives and we can all agree that life will be boring to a certain level without costumes.

Everybody likes to have the best costume for Halloween, costume parties, theatre and film events. Costumes help us make a statement about the message we want to pass across and a perfect costume brings out the holiday spirit.

If you are reading this article, then you are probably looking for the right costume for your next themed party. Well, you have come to the right place.

Below are some of the best costume stores in NYC which can cater to your costume needs and help you find just the best outfit for your upcoming event.

  • 1. Beyond Costumes
  • 2. Screaming Mimi’s
  • 3. Abracadabra NYC
  • 4. Euroco Costumes Inc.
  • 5. Costume Closet
  • 6. Bethany Joy Costumes Inc.
  • 7. Frank Bee Stores
  • 8. Early Halloween
  • 9. Reminiscence
  • 10. Gothic Renaissance
  • 11. Brooklyn Superhero Supply Co

1. Beyond Costumes

Location: 145 Saw Mill River Rd FL 3 Ste 31, Yonkers, NY 10701, United States

Contact:  +1 914-963-1333

Visit Website

Beyond Costumes


This costume store is more fun than you could ever imagine. Anything your imagination can dream about, Beyond Costumes, tries to make it a reality for you in every possible way.

They have a wide range of costumes available for rental and purchase. The categories available include mystical, occupation, ethnic, historical, novelty and fiction. So whether you want to dress like an astronaut, a princess or a magician, they have got you covered.

Costumes come out well when accompanied by accessories. Beyond Costumes has accessories such as wigs, masks, wands, fake cigars and many more to help complete the look you are going for.

All these costumes are available in both adult and children’s sizes, so don’t feel shy to drop in and shop. They also have shoes for rent to give you a complete transition.

2. Screaming Mimi’s

Location: 240 W 14th St, New York, NY 10011, United States

Contact:  +1 212-677-6464

Visit Website

Screaming Mimis


This little gem is a great vintage shop with amazing varieties of costumes and clothing. Screaming Mimi’s is a really good place to stop by New York City if you are hunting for vintage items.

If you want costumes that were the in-thing decades ago, this is the shop to visit. Everything here is from a fashion stylist’s point of view meaning they are the bomb!

The items here are meant to leave a lasting impression in the memories of those who set their eyes on you. This is why celebrities often visit this gem because of the amazing selection and so should you. The prices are not too pricey but you will love what you walk out with from this store.

3. Abracadabra NYC

Location: 19 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010, United States

Contact:  +1 212-627-5194

Visit Website

Abracadabra NYC


This massive store is located in the heart of New York City and is open all year round. Abracadabra has a great selection of costumes and accessories but with a price point to match.

From funny costumes, pet costumes, and group costumes to adult costumes, this store is where you need to be. The store has fabulous accessories such as wigs, fake beards, belts, fangs and teeth, headpieces and many more.

Abracadabra has props, make-up, masks, and apparel of all kinds to suit what you are looking for. In short, this place has almost everything you can think of. Why go to many stores to shop when you can simply shop in one store?

4. Euroco Costumes Inc.

Location: 306 W 38th St floor 16, New York, NY 10018, United States

Contact:  +1 212-629-9665

Visit Website

Euroco Costumes Inc.


This gem of a store is the best when it comes to theatrical costume supply in New York City. It is a goldmine for anyone interested in making custom costumes.

Euroco costumes specialize in Broadway costumes, television, movies and ballet. Their goal is to make quality costumes and that is why they use the best types of fabrics.

They also specialize in silicone fabric modification and if you are a vegan, you will find something suitable for you for they do vegan costuming. This store has amazing and quality costumes that are suitable and inclusive for everyone. If you are organizing a show and you need costumes, this is the place to be.

5. Costume Closet

Location: 83 Starr St, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States

Contact: +1 772-924-9070

Visit Website

Costume closet


If you are the kind of person who enjoys playing dress up then Costume Closet should be your go-to costume store.

We all want to make heads turn and make an unforgettable entrance when we go to a party and this store works towards achieving that goal. They have a wide range of costumes for rental and accessories to complement the costumes.

The team at Costume Closet are very creative and they help you curate the most amazing costume to satisfy your needs. You need to book an appointment beforehand so that they can be ready for you and help find the best possible outfit for you.

6. Bethany Joy Costumes Inc.

Location: 247 W 37th St #1800, New York, NY 10018, United States

Contact: +1 212-706-9977

Visit Website

Bethany Joy Costumes Inc.


If you can dream it, Bethany Joy costumes probably has it. This store has been serving the people of New York for years and the owner herself has experience in the costume industry and this is an added advantage.

Bethany Costumes boast of paying attention to details which makes the clothing here unique with a personal touch. They have a wide range of costumes and accessories to be paired with.

They have costumes fit for theatrical use that is opera, film, dance, fashion and more. They also do bridal alterations so if you are a private client, don’t be shy to contact them. Visit the store for the best costume experience.

7. Frank Bee Stores Inc.

Location: 3435 E Tremont Ave, The Bronx, NY 10465, United States

Contact: +1 718-823-9792

Visit Website

Frank Bee stores Inc.


This store is one of the largest providers of Halloween costumes in New York. Frank Bee Inc. prides themselves on providing the best quality of costumes at affordable prices.

They have a variety of costumes and accessories and the styles are just out of this world. They also have costumes for kids and adults of all ages and sizes.

Frank Bee also offers an array of items for sale and purchase. These include props, special effects, cotton candy machines and many others. With Halloween just around the corner, this is a great place to visit and get everything you need for the holiday.

8. Early Halloween

Location: 130 W 25th St #11, New York, NY 10001, United States

Contact: +1 212-691-2933

Visit Website

Early Halloween

If you are thinking of dressing in vintage costumes for Halloween, then Early Halloween is the place for you. This vintage costume shop is jam-packed with a lot of amazing vintage and antique costumes.

They have pieces that depict different decades and you will love them. They also have a lot of accessories that work well with the costumes you pick. Early Halloween has costumes for all age groups and you need to book an appointment before visiting them.  

9. Reminiscence

Location: 74 5th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

Contact: +1 212-243-2292



If you are into vintage costumes then Reminiscence is the gem you are looking for. This costume store has everything you need to make your Halloween a memorable one.

The store stocks costumes, accessories, retro novelty gifts and many more. You are bound to get amazing vintage costumes from several decades if that is what you are looking for.

If you are also looking to assemble any type of outfit for a themed party, then Reminiscence has your back. The staff will help you come up with something that you will love.

The prices are reasonable and they don’t allow refunds. This is why they help you out in every aspect of the costume so that you walk out of there feeling completely satisfied.

10. Gothic Renaissance

Location: 110 4th Ave, New York, NY 10003, United States

Contact:  +1 212-780-9558

Visit Website

Gothic Renaissance


As the name of the store suggests, the Gothic-Renaissance is the place to go for gothic and renaissance-related outfits and costumes.  The shop stocks an unlimited number of amazing costumes, gorgeous jewellery, unique shoes and many more.

I have heard a great deal about the types of corsets available and it is all praise for the quality and unique designs found in this store.  To let you in on a little secret, if you are looking for corsets or boots or anything that is in black, the Gothic renaissance should be the first place to run to.

11. Brooklyn Superhero Supply Co

Location: 372 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Contact: +1 718-499-9884

Visit Website

Brooklyn Superhero supply Co


This store is every superhero fan’s dream come true; this is one place you can go and become a superhero of your own. The store is jam-packed with costumes, capes, masks, gadgets and pretty much everything you can imagine that has to do with superheroes.

Brooklyn Superhero Supply is not just a store. It has a place where kids can come hang out with friends or even do their homework. There is also a learning centre in the back which is only accessible through the secret passage in the store. It is a really cool place for kids to visit.

Adults are also welcome to the store and they will find something suitable for them as well. You can also get great t-shirts and gifts for your loved ones.


The stores listed above will cater for your needs, whether it is a Halloween costume, themed party costume or whatever costume needs you have. There is no need to be boring yet there are so many options to explore. Better get your costume ready for Halloween is just around the corner.

Leave a Comment