10 Top-Rated Grocery Stores In New York City (Update 2022)

Looking for the best grocery stores in NYC for shopping? You are in the right place.

A grocery store is a go-to place that we all need to visit on a regular basis to grab our essentials, whether that be food for the week, toiletries, or cleaning supplies.

Inside an Grocery Store

We like a grocery store to be a place where we can buy all of our essentials in one place.

If you’re new to New York, you may be wondering what the best stores are to suit all of your grocery needs.

The best grocery stores in NYC:

  1. Morton Williams
  2. D’agostino
  3. Trader Joe’s
  4. Westside Market
  5. Zabars
  6. 4thStreet Co-op
  7. Citarella Gourmet Market
  8. Union Market
  9. Eataly
  10. C-Town Supermarkets

1. Morton Williams

140 W 57th St, New York, NY, 10019

+1 212 586 7750

Visit Site

Morton Williams


In total, there are fifteen Morton Williams stores dotted around New York City. They’re a family-owned retailer that has been in business since 1946.

You can expect to find all of your usual groceries at Morton Williams, and with fifteen stores located around the city, you can be sure to find one close by.

They have special offers each week, on a variety of different foods and drinks such as steaks at $12.99, California peaches at $3.99, and two packs of organic chips for $7.

As these are weekly offers, they will likely change but you can keep up to date via their website and social media platforms and will no doubt always find some great deals on your favorite foods.

As well as their location on 140 West, Morton Williams also has stores in the Flatiron district, the Upper East Side, and Midtown East.

The 140 West store is open 24/7.

2. D’Agostino

355 1st Ave, New York, NY, 10010

+1 212 353 2581

Visit Site



D’Agostino was founded in 1932 by Nicola and Pasquale D’Agostino after travelling from Italy to New York for a new life. It first opened as a small grocery store on Lexington Ave and since then has expanded across the city.

The grocery store has plenty of aisles for you to browse, including a fresh bakery section, a seafood counter, and hair and body care, meaning you should be able to get all of your shopping completed in one trip.

If you don’t fancy trekking out to the grocery store, then you can also opt for home delivery from D’Agostino.

There are over ten D’Agostino stores located across the city, so you should always be able to find one close by. The store located at 355 1st Ave is open seven days a week from 7 am to 10 pm.

3. Trader Joe’s

675 6th Ave, New York, NY, 10010

+1 212 255 2106

Visit Site

Trader Joes


Trader Joe’s is a national chain of grocery stores. The grocery store mainly focuses on its own branded products, so you won’t find as many of your favourite brands as what you might do at other grocery stores, however, you will be sure to find plenty of exciting and tasty new products under the Trader Joe’s label.

You’ll find all of your go-to aisles at Trader Joe’s such as fresh fruit and veg, dairy, and meat and seafood.

They have plenty of options available for you at amazing values such as organic chicken from $3.49 per lb or fresh burritos from $3.99, perfect for if you’re needing a light lunch that you can eat on the go.

If you head over to their website, you’ll also find plenty of recipes for breakfast, lunch, and dinner featuring cooking times, methods, and all the ingredients that are available to purchase from their stores, making dinner time much more exciting!

New York has over fifteen Trader Joe’s stores with the opening hours for the 675 6th Ave store from 8 am to 9 pm, seven days a week.

4. Westside Market

2589 Broadway, New York, NY, 10025

+1 212 316 0222

Visit Site

Westside Market


Westside Market is a family-owned business founded by John Zoitas, who originally came over to the US from Greece. Since then, he has been committed to offering his customers the best produce, catering services, and unique departments.

You’ll find all Westside Market stores well-stocked with departments including an organic aisle, a deli aisle, and a cheese aisle. They also have specialist departments for options such as gift baskets and even an olive and salad bar.

Westside Market has plenty of essentials to offer their customers along with speciality and gourmet items as well, just in case you fancy treating yourself to something extra special.

Westside Market has seven stores across New York City with the Broadway store open 24/7.

5. Zabar’s

2245 Broadway, New York, NY, 10024

+1 212 787 2000

Visit Site



Zabar’s first opened in 1934 by Louis and Lillian Zabar and has worked on growing the business over time. Now you can count on Zabar’s offering not only great food but also great service as well.

In the store, you can expect to find all of your grocery store essentials along with departments such as a deli and bakery. As well as these departments, Zabar’s also has its own branded products such as its delectable coffee beans and cheeses.

If you’re browsing for a loved one, they also have a variety of gift basket options available, which are perfect if you have a food-loving friend or family member’s birthday on the horizon.

A classic Zabar’s food basket would cost $175 and they also have baskets for nearly every occasion, whether that’s housewarming or get-well gifts.

 Zabar’s is open Monday to Saturday from 8 am to 7.30 pm and Sundays from 9 am to 6 pm.

6. 4thStreet Co-op

58 E 4th St, New York, NY, 10003

+1 212 674 3623

Visit Site

4thStreet Co op


4th Street Co-op is a grocery store where people have voluntarily met to provide the best organic, fair-trade, seasonal, and bulk products. Open to the public, they also offer discounts for SNAP recipients, students, seniors, and co-op members.

One of the only grocery stores to offer bulk shopping, you can purchase a variety of pantry items or dry goods from 4th Street Co-op such as beans, cereals, and pasta.

This is a handy option for large families or as a way to make a saving, especially if you have room to stock your dry foods.

All of their produce is grown to meet organic standards and sourced locally so you can always ensure that you’re purchasing only the highest quality of products, particularly as their prices are not for profit, you know they only have their customers at heart.

The store is open Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday from 12 pm to 8 pm, Wednesday from 4 pm to 8 pm, Saturday from 1 pm to 6 pm, and Sunday from 12 pm to 7 pm.

7. Citarella Gourmet Market

2135 Broadway, New York, NY, 10023

+1 212 874 0383

Visit Site

Citarella Gourmet Market


Citarella has been offering the freshest foods since 1912 and is known for selling “the finest fish in the city”. They’re a family run business that has stores on the Upper West Side, Upper East Side, and the West Village.

All of their fresh seafood is sustainably sourced, and you can always count on their helpful staff to give you the best advice on what seafood picks would work for you.

As well as their top fish selection, you can also expect to find a great choice of wines and other grocery essentials in the store. They also have a delivery option to deliver their fish nationwide.

If cooking from scratch isn’t your thing then you’ll also find a variety of ready prepared foods where all you need to do is heat up and eat. Pick from pasta, meats, seafood, and grain options.

The Upper West Side store is open seven days a week from 8 am to 8 pm.

8. Union Market

240 E Houston St, New York, NY, 10002

+1 212 677 2441

Visit Site

Union Market


There are five Union Markets located around New York City, all of which are dotted around Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Union Market describes itself as a neighbourhood grocery store that likes to bring its customers a mixture between everyday essentials and specially sourced foods.

Departments in Union Market include a cheese and dairy section, a bakery section, a prepared food section, and also a fresh selection of seafood and produce.

Union Market stocks a whopping 250 different variations of cheese for you to choose from, so if you’re looking for something with a unique taste then this grocery store is for you.

On top of that, they also have the freshest seafood available and also work with New York’s top bakers to bring you the highest quality bread and sweet treats.

The 240 E Houston St store is open seven days a week from 7.30 am to 9 pm.

9. Eataly

200 5th Ave, New York, NY, 10010

+1 212 229 2560

Visit Site



Eataly was founded in 2002 by Oscar Fairnetti who had sketched the entire concept on a piece of paper.

He wanted to provide high quality and sustainable food for everyone, while also celebrating his Italian culture and lifestyle. Fairnetti first opened Eataly’s doors in 2007 and has worked on expanding the grocery store ever since.

Eataly is “Eat” and “Italy” combined into one word and stands for “eating Italian”. Fairnetti has made sure this statement reigns true in all of his stores with all departments nodding toward all of the great food Italy has to offer.

You’ll find departments such as fresh food and pasta, and even a department specially dedicated to olive oils and different kinds of vinegar.

If you can’t make your way to an Eataly store, then they also have the option to shop online. The 200 5th Ave store is open seven days a week from 9 am to 10 pm.

10. C Town Supermarkets

188 Avenue C, New York, NY, 10009

+1 212 505 7577

Visit Site

C Town Supermarkets


C Town supermarkets are all individually owned supermarkets that work on allowing shop owners to create their own stores and reflect the individuality of the store’s neighbourhood.

Being a large supermarket, they have plenty of offers available to their customers every week, all of which are available to view on their website. You can expect to find offers such as an iced tea mix for $6.99, 2 for $5 on fresh salads, and spareribs for $3.49.

They also have a selection of recipes available on their website if you need some inspiration on what to cook for dinner with all ingredients available to purchase from their supermarkets.

There are over ten C Town stores in New York, so you’ll be sure to find one close to your area. The 188 Avenue C store is open Monday to Thursday from 8 am to 8 pm, Friday from 8 am to 8.30 pm, Saturday from 8 am to 8 pm, and Sundays from 8.30 am to 6 pm.


So, if there’s one thing you won’t be short of finding in New York City, it’s a grocery store. You’ll find them located in every area of the city with options ranging from well-known chains to smaller, independent stores.

There are plenty of New York stores that pride themselves on offering only the freshest of foods to their customers, particularly when it comes to seafood and organic produce.

These New York grocery stores are not just for your everyday essentials, but they also have options to send out a thoughtful gift basket or even have great choices if you fancy giving your taste buds an extra special treat.

Did you enjoy reading this story? Have you thought of any other exciting New York grocery stores? Why not share and comment your thoughts below?

Leave a Comment