23 Best Italian Restaurants In Brooklyn Of 2023 (Places For Italian Pasta)

Italian cuisine is made up of several dishes that are usually colorful, attractive, and fresh. Preparing Italian dishes involves a combination of the ingredients and other seasonings.

Traditionally, Italian dishes are often eaten in a family setting with both friends and family.

There are several Italian restaurants in Brooklyn that prepare authentic Italian recipes.

It all comes down to what restaurant you find to be suiting your taste buds.

While many other Italian-based restaurants have slightly changed the customs and traditions of food making, others have retained their culture.

This article is all about the Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, where to find them, and how to get the best out of these restaurants.

Here are some of the best Italian restaurants pick in Brooklyn.

1. Luzzo’s bk

Address; 145 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Contact; (718) 855-6400

The most commonly ordered food here is their pizza Margherita due to how perfectly they are made using high-quality ingredients.

That said, they also have other international food recipes that you can order in and enjoy.

It also features a wide range of wine lists for wine lovers and an outdoor setting to ensure you enjoy your food if you don’t want to dine inside the restaurant.

The prices of their food are reasonable, and the service is just on another level.

I would recommend dining inside the restaurant such that you won’t miss the liveliness in the restaurant.

I highly recommend this restaurant. If you cannot travel to Naples for real authentic Italian dishes, this restaurant will not disappoint you.

2. Savelli restaurant and bar

Address; 195 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Contact; (347) 889-7617

Savelli is one of the Best Restaurants Near Smith Street Brooklyn, it is family-owned and another place you would find classic and authentic Italian dishes.

The food and service are outstanding, with the staff helping out in making recommendations about what they offer.

There is also outdoor dining which gives more room should you find the indoors of the restaurant fully packed.

Technology is also of importance as the menu can easily be accessed via your phone.

They also offer a wide range of wines and cocktails to choose from. The prices are also affordable, and it’s definitely one restaurant you should visit. The coffee served is also unique and worth a try.

They do accept reservations, and you can book the date and time you want.

However, there are some restrictions recently because of the disease.

3. La casa Bella restaurant

Address; 2579 Cropsey Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, United States

Contact; 1 718-449-0200

Casa Bella restaurant blends traditional and modern cooking styles to make some of the best dishes you might not have tasted.

The restaurant owners have been preparing recipes by taking inspiration from their grandparents.

This restaurant is perfect if you have a large crowd because of the space in the restaurant.

They also have outdoor dining, but it’s not recommended, especially when the weather is cold.

They do have heaters on the outside but are so tall and might not eliminate the cold.

The only problem with outdoor dining is that space and tables are limited. Besides, the table is also placed next to the sidewalks.

Otherwise, they have very delicious authentic Italian recipes that you should try.

4. Puttanesca restaurant

Address; 202 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

Contact; 212 581 4177

If you are looking for a restaurant with delicious savory Italian cuisine, then Puttanesca is just the right one that fits your taste buds.

The restaurant primarily focuses on Sicilian cuisine and was first established in 1990.

The restaurant menu consists of both classic and modern recipes such as wagyu steaks.

This restaurant has several dining rooms, making it a perfect location if you want to host private parties or even special events.

The chef, who comes from Venice, Italy, has mastered several recipes from the classics and brings that passion to this restaurant.

Puttanesca also has a wide range of desserts that you cannot go without finding your favorite.

5. San Pietro

Address; 18 E 54th St, New York, NY 10022, United States

Contact; (212) 753-9015

San Pietro restaurant is considered one of the best restaurants outside Italy and has received an award from the Italian government and culinary organizations.

It is the best Italian restaurant outside Italy with classic and authentic Italian recipes.

The ingredients used to prepare foods in this restaurant are often imported from different provinces in Italy.

As a result, their food is usually well-balanced and healthy diets.

They have both indoor and outdoor dining with a wide range of dishes to choose from. They also have a wide range of wines.

However, the food prices are slightly higher, which means you need to carry extra cash.

6. Sistina

Address; 24 E 81st St, New York, NY 10028, United States

Contact; (212) 861-7660

This restaurant has been there for about 40 years in New York. The owner Giuseppe Bruno has been the reason behind the success of this restaurant. They primarily focus on northern Italian cuisine.

Signature dishes include fusilli with broccoli rabe, veal and mushroom, and many other recipes.

The food and drinks are slightly expensive, but it’s worth every single penny.

The outdoor dining is super beautiful, thanks to the scope of the street.

The inside is also beautiful and lively as the staff engages you in what they offer.

They also have different varieties of wine, primarily Italian. It is one restaurant you should definitely check out.

7. L and B spumoni gardens

Address; 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223, United States

Contact;  +1 718-372-8400

This restaurant is primarily known for its Sicilian-style pizzas. Besides preparing pizzas, their menu is full of other dishes such as salads and ices.

It was initially established as an ice and spumoni before adding Sicilian pizza to their menu.

Their signature ice is prepared by the combination of almond, chocolate, and pistachio.

It is one of the most delicious dessert ices in Brooklyn.

Their pizzas are generally square or rectangular ever since the restaurant was established.

There is nothing fancy about their pizzas. The only difference is the procedure used when preparing the pizza.

The prices are also affordable, and it makes a must-try restaurant should you find yourself within Brooklyn.

8. Evelina restaurant

Address; 211 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, United States

Contact; (929) 298-0209

When at this restaurant, it all comes down to your mindset. It’s usually all about the pasta when at this restaurant.

You should know that this is a Mediterranean restaurant with the only difference being the solid Italian overtones.

The restaurant owner doesn’t specialize in preparing specific food recipes and tends to alter the menu based on what food type is fresh and selling in the market.

This restaurant is spacious with dim lights that make it the most incredible place for romantic dates or family.

The seafood served here is super delicious, and you might want to stick to the pasta regardless of what the staff tells you.

This is because pasta is served with several meat varieties on the side.

9. love and dough restaurant

address; 57 Pearl St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

contact; (347) 987-3404

This restaurant is situated next to the Manhattan Bridge, and they primarily prepare several Italian recipes from different regions in Italy.

Pizza is one of their signature dishes, and it is prepared using high-quality ingredients such as the Caputo flour imported from Italy.

The prices of the dishes are affordable, and the only limitation is you can only pay using cash which is one factor you should consider.

They also serve gluten-free pizzas to accommodate different taste buds.

The food is affordable. The space is slightly undersized, and when fully packed, there is noise from within the restaurant.

10. Di Farra pizza

Address; 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230, United States

Contact; (718) 258-1367

It is one of the oldest restaurants in Brooklyn. Food critics have time and again referred to this restaurant as one of the best for pizzas.

The ingredients and the procedures involved when making their pizzas is what make them stand out.

Well, when at di Farra restaurant you need to practice patience because the queues can sometimes become unbearable.

Demarco, the restaurant’s owner, does inspect every pizza to ensure they are perfect, making the queues too long.

The wait is worth it because of how good the pizzas are. The ingredients used are always imported, which is what makes the pizzas burst with unique flavors.

11. Mama Capri

Address; 247 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States

Contact; (917) 909-0237

The backyard of this coastal Italian restaurant is what makes it stand out. The food menu includes a wide range of food varieties, from salads to pasta.

The service is one you would love, and the staff is amicable, keeping you informed about what they offer.

It is essential you make reservations before going into this restaurant because it does get full.

It is also a low-key restaurant that makes it the perfect destination for having a conversation.

The price and quality of the food are not something you should worry about because the food is of high-quality and affordable.

12. Queen Italian restaurant

Address; 84 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Contact; +1 718-596-5955

This restaurant has been serving the residents of New York Italian dishes for over six decades, and they do it just perfectly.

It is a family-owned business that has continued to prove its doubters wrong with each passing year.

Food menus have been evolving in this restaurant, with both innovation and quality being their focus points.

The dishes prepared in this restaurant are inspired by the flavors made from twenty peninsula regions in Italy.

They have a bakery in the restaurant in which they make specialty bread, pasta, fish, and cheeses.

The appearance might not be appealing, but the food is definitely delicious.

13. Piccola cucina osteria siciliana

Address; 196 Spring St, New York, NY 10012, United States

contact; +1 646-478-7488

This restaurant has a wide variety of dishes on its menu, and it ranges from seafood, appetizers, pasta, chicken, and many others.

The chef is very attentive when it comes to choosing the ingredients used for food preparation.

The ingredients are handpicked by the cooks directly from the local markets.

The prices of the food are affordable but vary with the type of food ordered.

Also, they have outdoor dining, which is beautiful if you don’t feel like dining inside the restaurant.

Should you visit this restaurant, pasta is the one dish you should not miss ordering.

It is essential you book reservations before going to the restaurant because it sometimes is packed with many people.

The space might not be large enough, but the food is super delicious.

14. Pizza secret

Address; 72 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, United States

Well, Pizza Secret doesn’t prepare only pizzas as there are several other Italian cuisines on their menu.

In addition, Pizza Secret restaurant is just next to the Barclays center, which means you can easily access the restaurant from the subway.

The Neapolitan pizzas are affordable, and so is the quality of the pizzas.

They also serve salads and appetizers, which are perfectly done using high-quality ingredients.

The wine list in the restaurant is not that long, but they do have some delicious wines.

You should definitely head to this restaurant if you are craving pizza.

15. Santa panza restaurant

Address; 1079 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, United States

Contact; (347) 413-9695

Pizzas in this restaurant are prepared using wood-fired brick ovens.

The restaurant is beautifully decorated with an open dining room that is close to the bar and the kitchen.

The staff are friendly and do greet every guest that comes into the restaurant.

They also serve savory dishes with Mediterranean flavors. The restaurant might seem small without enough space, but the staff creates seats that were not there, especially when the restaurant is fully packed.

Santa Panza only accepts cash. You can dine both inside the restaurant, and outdoor the prices of the food are also affordable.

It would be best if you tried it out when in Brooklyn.

16. Larina pastificio and vino

Address; 387 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, United States

Contact; (718) 852-0001

When it comes to food in New York, there are certain things that you have to comprise for you to get the best dishes.

It usually is all about money, time, and space. At Larina restaurant, you don’t have to worry about any of the factors above.

The signature dish in this restaurant is pasta. So, you might want to go big on pasta when in Larina restaurant.

That said, there are several other dishes on their menu that may also entice you besides the pasta.

17. Gino’s trattoria and brick oven pizza

Address; 548 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, United States

Contact; +1 347-663-5452

This restaurant is family-owned and mainly serves Italian cuisine. The family often inspires the dishes made in this restaurant.

It was first established in 1985 and has been evolving ever since with several international dishes prepared.

The good news is you can order any food recipe online. The best would be to order from their official website as there are no extra charges.

The restaurant might be small, but the food is just so delicious.

The portions served are more than enough, which means there is definitely value of money. The prices of the food are affordable, and the service is good.

18. Macosa trattoria

Address; 310 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, United States

Contact; (646) 574-7866

Well, this Italian restaurant is all about comfort good, and it is super delicious.

The ingredients used in preparing the foods are just so fresh, usually collected by the chefs directly from the local markets.

Marcosa restaurant is still new in the neighborhood and business, but they are off to a perfect start. The backyard space is relatively small but at the same time beautiful.

The prices are affordable, and there are several other dishes on their menu that you can choose from.

It might not be popular, but this restaurant is upcoming and serves authentic Italian dishes.

19. Giovanni’s Brooklyn eats

Address; 1657 8th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Contact; +1 718-788-8001

This restaurant is located in a tranquil block just around the corner of prospect avenue but with several Italian dishes.

The food served here is classics which are often well done.

When at this restaurant, go for the bottomless brunch, which does come with an appetizer and a perfectly done entrée.

The good news is the brunch comes at a very affordable price.

You can dine inside or outside the restaurant, but the space inside the restaurant is limited. So outdoor dining might be the best option.

The menu at Giovanni’s Brooklyn eats changes frequently, but the quality is often outstanding.

They also are transparent in case of any additional charges applied either on credit or debit cards.

20. Forma pasta factory

Address; 14 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

Contact; +1 718-349-2009

This restaurant is still new and mainly serves fast food. You need to make the order from the counter, after which you sit anywhere within the restaurant as your hand-made pasta is prepared.

They have an open concept kitchen where you can easily watch as your pasta is being prepared.

The pasta is fresh and often cook from a point you can see. In addition, their menu comprises several other dishes besides pasta, such as salads.

They use high-quality ingredients often imported from Italy. Therefore, the prices of the dishes prepared in Forma are affordable.

The only change is the method of food preparation; otherwise, the flavor is just as good.

21. Cecconi’s Dumbo

Address; 55 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Contact; (718) 650-3900

This restaurant offers the perfect viewpoint for the Manhattan bridge and the New York skyline.

It is a modern-day Italian restaurant with several classic Italian dishes that have been flawlessly executed.

They do have a private dining space in the restaurant that can easily accommodate different events.

The dishes served here are mainly seafood, hand-made pasta, and Italian recipes.

The service is excellent and the price of the food is affordable. They also serve several cocktails that taste good.

It would be best if you tried the Negroni matsuri cocktail. It is super delicious.

If you have never been to this restaurant, you should head out there if you have the time.

More about Cecconi’s Dumbo

22. Montesacro pinseria

Address; 432 Union Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

Contact; (347) 916-1062

This restaurant is named after a neighborhood found in Rome where only working-class people eat and rest.

Classic Italian recipes inspire their dishes with a little twist to make them taste even better.

Their signature dish is the oval-shaped pinsa and does go for about $20.

The pinsa is made using wheat flour, rice, and soy sauce, all directly imported from Italy. It is a healthy dish with low amounts of calories.

The backyard of the restaurant is beautiful, and the retractable roof adds more space. The service is excellent.

The menu is full of other Italian dishes, but pinsa is a must-try when at this restaurant.

The cocktails and beers are also worth trying. They are just as good as the dishes.

23. Da Nonna Rosa

Address; 140 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Contact; +1 718-788-6225

This restaurant has primarily become famous because of its well-crafted pizzas. However, they also have other Italian dishes on their menu, which are just as delicious.

In addition, they have authentic Italian dishes like the classic Margherita pizza.

It was first established in 2010. Since then, they have introduced different types of dishes to their menu, all perfectly done.

They do have a private dining room spacious enough to accommodate many people and different events.

The service is excellent, and the food comes at an affordable price.

The portions are also large enough, and the good news is you can easily customize the food to your liking.

To explore more dining options, be sure to check out the guides listed below for a variety of other recommended restaurants.

Leave a Comment