Best Italian Restaurants In Park Slope (15 Places To Have An Authentic Italian Experience)

Park Slope is located within an area formerly known as South Brooklyn, and it is one of the best neighbourhoods to visit when you are in New York City.

It is a vibrant community filled with people from different races and backgrounds and it is one of the safest neighbourhoods in Brooklyn.

The safety, peace and serenity of the place attracts a lot of people to it. It hosts some of the best restaurants, salons, spas, fitness centres, architecture, and arts.

So, if you happen to find yourself on this side of town and you have some cravings for Italian dishes, you will find some of the best Italian restaurants in Park Slope.

These restaurants serve Italian classics ranging from pasta, pizza, and different selections of wine to other traditional Italian Cuisine recipes. Let us explore some of the best Italian Restaurants in Park Slope.

  • 1. Pasta Louise
  • 2. Provini
  • 3. Piccoli Trattoria
  • 4. Ottava
  • 5. Convivium Osteria
  • 6. Bar Toto
  • 7. Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats
  • 8. Scottadito Osteria
  • 9. Broccolino
  • 10. La Villa Pizzeria
  • 11. Mariella
  • 12. Fausto
  • 13. Bella Gioia
  • 14. Flora
  • 15. Al Di La Trattoria

1. Pasta Louise

Location: 1114 8th ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: 347-725-3883

Visit Website

Pasta Louise 1


The owners of Pasta Louise opened this lovely place during the Covid-19 pandemic and they immediately turned it into an enviable enigma in Park Slope. Pasta Louise is known far and wide for its fresh and delicious pasta recipes.

Pasta Louise is a beautiful community pasta restaurant where you can hang out with friends, enjoy fresh pasta, and sip your glass of amazing wine.

The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating options and the inner space can hold about seventy people.

You will also enjoy their sauces and bread which they make from scratch, and the menu for each day consists of a different kind of pasta.

This is a lively and family-friendly restaurant that you can visit when you are in Park Slope.

2. Provini

Location: 1302 8th Ave at 13th St Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: (718) 369-2154

Visit Website

Provini New


Some refer to Provini as a hidden jewel in Park Slope, and you might not understand the reason for this name until you have experienced it for yourself.

This beautiful restaurant has an intimate and cosy seating arrangement both inside and outside.

This is another lovely Italian spot where you will enjoy house made fresh pasta which is quite irresistible.

You will also love this place because of its extensive wine list, including sustainable and organic wines.

3. Piccoli Trattoria

Location: 522 6th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: 718-788-0066

Visit Website

Piccoli New


Visiting Piccoli is an opportunity for you to enjoy homemade cuisines made with quality ingredients and the best hands.

Two things that stand out about this place are their simplicity and quality; they use the simplest ingredients and transform them into something spectacular.

Another thing that will impress you about this place is that they ship their buffalo mozzarella and Proscuitto di Parma from Napoli every week. This ensures top quality, and they also use antibiotic-free and hormone-free chicken.

You will also love their fresh pasta and loaves of bread because they are made in house. Their menu contains pastis, entrees and risotto dishes.

One outstanding risotto dish is made with wild rice, mushrooms, butternut squash, organic chicken, ricotta Salata, parsley, calamari, and white wine.

4. Ottava

Location: 1123 Eighth Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: 718-369-0493

Visit Website

Ottava New


Ottava is a beautiful and elegant restaurant where you can enjoy beautiful wine, elegant and tasty cocktails, and mouthwatering dishes. If you love quality pizzas, you will enjoy their artisanal pizzas made with care and attention.

If you visit this place you should try their fried chicken, mushroom pizza, and their polo salad, they are all amazing and delicious.

They have room for both indoor and outdoor seating arrangements, and if you are planning a private event or going with a group above 5, then you need to call and make reservations.

5. Convivium Osteria

Location: 68 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217 Park Slope near Barclays Center

Contact: (718) 857-1833

Visit Website

Convivium New


Convivium Osteria is a lovely neighbourhood restaurant that opened in 2000 and has been serving the needs of the community for a long time.

As one of the most Romantic Restaurants in Brooklyn, it offers the people of Park Slope authentic Italian cuisines and wines.

The ingredients used here are of high quality and some are shipped directly from Italy, you will experience authentic Italian hospitality at this lovely spot.

The atmosphere in this restaurant is romantic, and it is a lovely place to go for a romantic date.

The restaurant has a private dining space which can be found in the rustic wine cellar downstairs. You can call them ahead of time and book this private spot for an intimate experience.

6. Bar Toto

Location: 411 11th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: (718) 768-4698

Visit Website

Bar Toto New


It is always lovely and exciting to find a restaurant that has both comfortable indoor and outdoor seating.

Bar Toto is one of those restaurants that has a divine decor and exotic atmosphere. Plus the Italian food served here is one of the best in the area.

Their pasta, panini, and pizza are delicious and well-prepared, and you will be impressed with the artfully constructed entrees like organic salmon, organic chicken Parmigiana, and organic chicken salad.

The desserts served here are also delicious and amazing and it is a lovely place to hang out with your family.

They also have an extensive selection of Italian wines and other alcoholic beverages to accompany your meal.

7. Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats

Location: 1657 8th Avenue – Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: (718) 788-8001

Visit Website

Giovanni New


Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats is a restaurant that offers you an authentic Italian experience. You will find real Italian dishes prepared from traditional Italian recipes, made with only fresh and quality ingredients.

The staff here is passionate about their work and you can feel this in the quality of the food and the services offered here.

The atmosphere here is welcoming and homely, especially with the vintage family photos on the wall.

The seating arrangement is comfortable, you can seat outdoors by the sidewalk, indoors, or you can seat by the Italian herb garden.

8. Scottadito Osteria

Location: 788A Union Street, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: 718-636-4800

Visit Website

Scottadito New


Scottadito Osteria is a restaurant you must visit if you are looking for a true Italian dining experience.

This lovely restaurant has served the Park Slope community for more than a decade and you will be thrilled by the traditional Italian dishes served here.

As you go through their extensive menu, you will find amazing dishes like the delicious pesto chicken and their mouthwatering eggs benedict. Another exciting thing about this place is that they cure their own meat.

If you visit this place, then you should try their house-made speck, Proscuitto, ricotta gnocchi, lamb chops, and their fried artichokes; they are delicious.

9. Broccolino

Location: 446 Dean Street Brooklyn, NY 11217

Contact: (929) 276-3995

Visit Website

Broccolino New


Broccolino is a lovely restaurant that encourages people to eat healthily. Their menu is made up of delicious and irresistible dishes that will make you go back for more.

If you love fresh pasta, you will love the house-made pasta dishes they serve every day including their thin crust pizza which is the best in the area.

The restaurant has a casual and intimate atmosphere that makes you feel comfortable and at home the moment you step in.

This spot is perfect for a Sunday brunch or brunch during the week, and if you are attending any events in the Barclays Centre, you can drop in for some authentic Italian treat.

10. La Villa Pizzeria

Location: 261 5th Ave, New York, NY 11215

Contact: (718) 499-9888

Visit Website

La Villa New


If you want a restaurant that specializes in good pizza, you do not need to look any further. La Villa Pizzeria is one of those few restaurants that make amazing authentic Italian pizza and dishes.

It is a family run business which has maintained its traditional Italian hospitality and recipes. Their perfectly cooked focaccia bread, garlic pizza, and calamari will blow your mind.

Other things on their menu that you might fall in love with are chocolate cakes, cheesecakes and tiramisu.

You will also enjoy their delicious espresso, beer, and tasty margaritas. The seating arrangement is comfortable and elegant, and the bar has a calm and lovely atmosphere where you can relax and enjoy your meal.

11. Mariella

Location: 492 6TH AVE BROOKLYN, NY, 11215

Contact: 718-499-2132

Visit Website

Mariella New


If you love and crave Italian food, then the authentic Italian dishes served at Mariella might become your best new thing.

Their perfectly cooked risotto, rigatoni, and scallops will make you change your favorite Italian restaurant.

The intimate and relaxing atmosphere of the restaurant makes it the perfect place to hang out and have some hearty meal after a busy and hectic day.

You will also get top quality service at this restaurant because the staff are friendly and welcoming.

Mariella restaurant uses only organic animal products, sourced from local farmers. And if you are sensitive to gluten, then you will be pleased with the gluten-free options on the menu.

12. Fausto

Location: 348 Flatbush Ave. — Brooklyn, NY

Contact: 917-909-1427

Visit Website

Fausto New


Fausto is a neighbourhood restaurant that caters to the cravings of many people in the community. This restaurant is deeply rooted in authentic Italian tradition, and you will find some modern variations of Italian traditional dishes.

Chef Erin Shambura and Joe Campanale the wine expert are the team behind the goodness that comes from the kitchen.

The amazing thing is that the restaurant samples ingredients and wines straight from Italy, and these are very affordable for diners.

If you visit this restaurant, then you have to try their tender braised pork, delicate rice balls, and the quadrello di bufala cheese; they are excellent.

The restaurant has a sleek look with a modern and mid-century design that is pleasing and exciting from the moment you step into the restaurant.

13. Bella Gioia

Location: 209 4th Ave. Brooklyn, NYC 11217 (Union Street R stop)

Contact: 347-223-4176

Visit Website

Bella Gioia New


Bella Gioia is a lovely Italian restaurant that specializes in serving Sicilian comfort food. You will have a charming dining experience here because every dish is prepared with utmost care, and they use only the finest ingredients to guarantee quality.

They have a seasonal menu that takes advantage of the freshest ingredients available at different seasons of the year, and this ensures that the menu is not boring.

You will find authentic Italian traditional recipes which have been handed down from one generation to another.

The chef and staff at Bella Gioia share this traditional family flavors and hospitality with you in an elegant and comfortable atmosphere that makes you feel at home.

14. Flora

Location: 1021 8th Ave Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: 347.844.9480

Visit Website

Flora New


Flora restaurant is a beautiful spot where you can enjoy authentic Italian dishes in an artistic and warm environment.

This place is exciting in the sense that they use premium quality ingredients, and the meals have a touch of authenticity, simplicity, and they use fresh and seasonal ingredients.

If you are among those who love brunch, then their brunch menu will make you fall in love with this place because you will have more than enough to eat.

You can also hang out here for lunch and dinner, they have a lovely menu, and a great selection of beer, wine, and cocktails.

They have a creative salad menu that is filled with goodies, and if you ever visit them then you need to try out their salad and tuna.

They have both indoor and outdoor seating arrangements which are all comfortable and perfect for different occasions and seasons.

15. Al Di La Trattoria

Location: 248 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Contact: +1 (718) 783-4565

Visit Website

Al Di La new


Al Di La Trattoria is a family-run restaurant that offers you a true and authentic Italian dining experience. If you love pasta, then you will enjoy the fresh homemade pasta made by this restaurant.

This beautiful restaurant is filled with natural lighting during the day, and at night the place is warmly lit with candles making the place intimate and romantic. It is the perfect spot to take your partner for a romantic Italian dinner experience.

One of the things you will enjoy here is their exciting salad menus; you can try the roasted squash with farro, and cauliflower. Also, the pasta and chicken dishes are some of the interesting options on their menu.

This spot is perfect for those who appreciate great food, good wine, and a lovely atmosphere.


Most people love Italian dishes because of the different variety of ingredients that go into preparing the dishes, and I am sure this is one of the reasons why you appreciate it as well.

So, if you are hoping to have one of the best Italian experiences while in Park Slope, the restaurants above happen to be some of the best in the area.

Pin it!

Classic Italian food setting with pizza

Leave a Comment