Best Pizza Spots in Times Square (10 Places You Should Try)

Pizza is a household name, and among the most important aspects that characterize a city is the availability of places to grab one whenever you feel like. New York City has been home to the most delicious pizza.

Times Square, a commercial intersection in Manhattan, seats some of New York’s best pizza restaurants you need to try out!

To help you get the best pizzas in Times Square, I have compiled a list of 10 places you need to visit at least once and explore what they offer. Read on.

10 of the Best Pizza Spots in Times Square, NYC

  1. Johns of Times Square
  2. Patzeria Perfect Pizza
  3. Little Italy Pizza
  4. Radio City Pizza
  5. Angelo’s Pizza
  6. Joe’s Pizza
  7. Pasta Lovers
  8. Paul’s on Times Square
  9. Don Antonio
  10. Carnegie Pizza

1. John’s Pizzeria

260 W. 44th Street, New York, NY 10036

Phone: 212-391-7560

Visit website

Johns Pizzeria

Source

Johns of Times Square, a pizza spot once voted one of New York’s best pizzas, sits in the former Gospel Tabernacle Church.

It opened its doors in 1997 when Madeline Castellotti, a single mother with a vision for a pizza spot, brought her dream to life.

The woman who was a human resource manager in one big law firm resigned to try her hands in the pizza business, not knowing how big her dream would blow.

Johns of Times Square makes all its pizzas using their four old coal-fired brick ovens that make different pizzas each time— no two pizzas come out similar.

The ovens with no thermostat for heat control are operated by pizza men who went through thorough training for months to become experts.

John’s Pizzeria’s pizza menu features traditional pizza made of mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce, Margherita, pizza Bianca, buffalo chicken pizza, Hawaiian, and bruschetta pizzas.

To garnish their unique tasting pizza, they serve with toppings such as breaded chicken cutlet, arugula, extra cheese, hot cherry peppers, and meatballs.

If you are craving pizza, drive down to Times Square of Manhattan, and have your fill at John’s Pizzeria. The spot is open daily (11:30 am – 11:30 pm)

It closes during Thanksgiving and Christmas days. On Christmas and New Year’s Eve, it opens from 11:30 am to 4:00 pm, and on New Year’s day, it’s open between 12:00 pm – 11:30 pm.

2. Patzeria Perfect Pizza

231 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036,

Phone: 212-575-7646

Visit website

Patzeria Perfect Pizza

Source

Whenever you’re in the mood of taking something delicious, think of Patzeria Perfect Pizza. It’s one of the most famous pizza spots in the city that you should visit for a classic experience of New York style pizza.

They offer exclusive pizza flavors, and it would be best if you visit this spot with an empty stomach as they serve generous slices of pizza alongside other food.

Also, this is it if you’re looking for a place with the best customer service. The customer service here is top-notch, with kind-hearted staff who value their clients and approach them respectfully.

Due to Covid 19, you’ll find all the staff in masks and observing the pandemic’s rules. Therefore don’t wonder if you find no seating places, as they currently prefer you eat your pizza while standing or as a takeaway.

You can place an order for delivery or pick up at your convenience. They accept credit cards, making it easier for your pizza to reach you even sooner.

For delivery, they are open on Monday (5:00 pm – 11:30 pm), Tuesday (5:00 pm – 10:30 pm), Wednesday through Saturday (4:00 pm – 10:30 pm), and Sunday (5:00 pm – 10:30 pm).

On the other hand, pick-up is done from Sunday through Tuesday (5:00 pm – 11:30 pm), Wednesday to Thursday (12:00 pm – 11:30 pm), and on Saturday, pick-ups are open (11:00 am – 11:30 pm)

3. Little Italy Pizza

55 West 45th St, New York, NY 10036

phone: 212-730-7575

Visit website

Little Italy Pizza

Source

Little Italy Pizza is another top-quality and world-famous pizza spot in the heart of Manhattan on 45th street. The spot was established in 1965, and since then, it has been providing world-class services and the highest quality pizzas to its clients—both locals and foreigners.

For over 55 years now, the place has been a staple point serving the people of Times Square, also known as Theater District and Manhattan, with quick bites and outside catering for large crowds.

Little Italy Pizza menu features a variety of pizza flavors. You’ll find Neapolitan Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza, Vodka Sauce with Fresh Mozzarella Pizza, Primavera Pizza, and Creamy Spinach & Artichoke Pizzato, to mention a few. In other words, there is something for everyone in this spot!

Due to covid 19, Little Italy Pizza operates on pick-ups and delivery. Their open hours are Monday to Friday from 9 am to 8 pm for in-person picking and home delivery. It remains closed on weekends.

4. Radio City Pizza

142 W 49th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

Phone: +1 212-843-3747

Radio City Pizza

Source

Radio City Pizza is a home for homemade pizza in New York. The spot is one of the best places to visit for a bite, especially if you’re a gluten-free pizza person.

The staff in this pizza space are friendly, investing all their time in customer satisfaction. In addition, you’ll get various dietary options like vegan and dairy-free mozzarella and gluten-free pizzas.

The restaurant features a small space to the inside, with a couple of tables inside and on their outside patio. It has a relaxed atmosphere attracting many people, especially those touring the city.

Its popularity is increased by its closeness to hotels that host tourists and some of the important sites of attraction, such as M&M World.

5. Angelo’s Pizza

1697 Broadway (b/n) 53rd &54th Street) New York, NY, 10019

Phone: 212 245-8811

Visit website

Angelos Pizza

Source

Another gem in New York City is this one here, Angelo’s Pizza! They offer an extensive pizza menu in a calm environment suitable for dining out.

Talk of courteous staff! You’ll find them in this spot. Once you come in, they’ll receive you with much respect and ensure you’re all satisfied. Who doesn’t want such an experience?

To top up their best services, you’ll never go wrong regardless of the pizza type you choose. They offer fantastic pizza flavors made using a coal-fired brick oven.

The spot offers both dine-in and pick-up and delivery services. A pizza date out? Try them, and you’ll love the place. You can also order your sweet and crusty pizzas and enjoy them from your home.

Angelo’s Pizza is open: Monday-Thursday 11:30 am–3:00 am (Next Day), Friday-Saturday 11:30 am–3:00 am (Next day), and on Sunday 11:30 am–3:00 am (Next day). Their store’s operating hours may vary, so you should contact the store in advance.

6. Joe’s Pizza

1435 Broadway, New York, NY 10018

Phone: 646-559-4878

Visit website

Joes Pizza

Source

Joe’s Pizza is another exceptional place for outstanding pizzas in New York. If you are not in the mood to get to the kitchen, make your way to Joe’s Pizza, that’s easier. This is a real find.

Grabbing a piece of pizza anytime you feel like it has never been easier than it is with Joe’s Pizza. You can place an order and receive it immediately, right at your door.

The spot features top-quality pizzas on its menu with dietary options such as gluten-free pizzas. Its extensive menu makes it a go-to place since there is always something for everybody.

For delivery, Joe’s Pizza opens Sunday to Wednesday (10:00 am – 2:00 am), Thursday(10:00 am – 1:00 am), and Friday and Saturday (10:00 am – 3:45 am).

If you need to pick your pizza yourself, picking hours are Sunday to Wednesday (10:00 am – 2:45 am), on Thursday, it opens (10:00 am – 3:30 am), and on Friday and Saturday, it’s open (10:00 am – 4:45 am)

Stop by for the tastiest pizza in New York!

7. Pasta Lovers

142 West 49th Street, New York, NY 10019

Phone: 212-819-1155

Visit website

Pasta Lovers

Source

Located in Rockefeller Plaza and Theater District, Pasta Lovers Trattoria has been a neighborhood hang-out spot for more than 15 years now. It prides itself in serving its clients fresh and delicious Italian cuisine.

For pizza lovers, this is such a find. It serves fresh, hot, and crusty pizzas made using its vast brick oven. Even though it is a fully packed restaurant with several other delectable cuisines, it is the place to turn to for a quick bite.

You can enjoy your pizza from the restaurant’s classic tables or order it for delivery to your door based on how you like it.

8. Paul’s on Times Square

136 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: 212-204-7246

Visit website

Pauls on Times Square

Source

In expanding your culinary horizons, don’t forget to try Pauls on Times Square for their delectable pizza varieties. It’s one of New York’s pizza points you need to discover if you’ve not yet.

The restaurant’s menu features pizza varieties that include Margarita, Quattro Formaggio, Prosciutto Di Parma, Make Your Own, and Neapolitan pizzas.

Try out Prosciutto Di Parma, which features mozzarella with prosciutto, arugula, fig jam, and parmesan cheese, one of their signature offerings, and you’ll keep coming for more.

For pick and delivery, Paul’s on Times Square is open throughout the week from 12 pm to 9 pm. Please make your order and enjoy their outstanding flavors.

9. Don Antonio

309 West 50th Street (at 8th Ave.) New York, NY 10019

Phone:646.719.1043

Visit website

Don Antonio

Source

Don Antonio, a pizza hub in the heart of Hell’s Kitchen and Theater District, is where you’ll find all your pizza varieties. With their menu overseen by Giorgia Caporuscio, a young lady pizzaiola, the restaurant is known for the best Neapolitan pizza.

The spot offers over 45 types of Neapolitan pizzas to the Manhattan people and its environs. Georgina, the world-renowned and revered pizzaiola, added to the existing Neapolitan pizzas another 7 fried pizzas to make the place a dream for pizza lovers.

Like many pizza places, Don Antonio offers dietary options on their menu, such as gluten-free or dairy-free pizzas. There is no better place to satisfy your craving than Don Antonio.

Its hours of operation are Monday to Sunday from 11:30 am to 10.00 pm. For delivery, the spot operates from Monday to Sunday (11: 00 am to 9:50 pm).

10. Carnegie Pizza

200 West 41st Street, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (212) 777-4141

Visit website

Carnegie Pizza

Source

In Times Square’s heart, Carnegie Pizza offers the most refined pizza tastes. If you’re looking for a place to satisfy your craving, find your way here, and luckily, you’ll not be disappointed.

Carnegie pizza was opened in 2020 by Jonathan, who grew up in the hospitality and restaurant industry. His father had almost all businesses under the sun. He worked in restaurants for a long time, and in 2018, he decided to take his path and open his own business.

After a little delay by Covid 19, the restaurant started operations in 2020. Jonathan came in with the piazza recipes he had learned back in the other businesses, and the outcome has been the best.

Its menu features several pizza types, including pepperoni, chicken, cheese, grand, and many more.

Hours

  • Monday – Thursday:11:00 am – 12:00 am
  • Friday:12:00 am – 1:00 am  11:00 am – 12:00 am
  • Saturday – Sunday:12:00 am – 2:00 am  11:00 am – 12:00 am

Wrap Up

As you might have known, New York has no competitor in curating the best pizzas. It hosts most of the famous pizza spots. Times Square has a fair share of such restaurants in the city.

I know many restaurants are offering high-quality pizzas in New York-Times Square- but this is a list of a few of the best where I know you’ll stumble on your favorite pizza style without much struggle.

What do you think? Is there one of the restaurants that you strongly believe should have been on the list? Feel free to engage us in the comment section.

Leave a Comment