Best Pizza Williamsburg, Brooklyn – 21 Places You Can Go

Am I the only one who craves pizza at least once a week? If you live in Williamsburg or are just visiting and would like to have some of the best pizzas, we have you covered.

Consider the best pizza Williamsburg places we suggest below.

Remember, Williamsburg is at the top regarding diversity in New York. Whether it’s food, culture, or people, diversity is evident.

You will be amazed that you get some of the best and different styles of pizza here.

Best Pizza In Williamsburg, Brooklyn

1. Best pizza

Whenever you crave the woodfired pizza, you should visit this spot in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

It’s a simple yet small and sophisticated spot serving precisely what you need for the pizza craving.

It features a century-old wood pizza oven that will make it easy to cook some of the most fantastic pizza slices.

It blends different cultures and Sicilian culture, heritage, and New York culture to make the different pizzas.

When you’re looking for the high-quality pizza slices of Brooklyn, then this is where you want to stay.

Thanks to chef Pinello, the owner of this restaurant and continues to wow us with his antiques.

Phone: 718) 599-2210


Visit website

2. Williamsburg pizza

This restaurant has many spots around New York, but I love the one in Williamsburg.

The one thing you will like about this place is that they deliver some of the best and yet delicious pizza easily thus memorable.

If you like to take the funky style of pizzas, you will like this kind of pizza. It features a thick cheese pizza that you can use when you need to enjoy the pizza.

It will amaze you that it’s one of the best pizzas you will encounter.

Phone: (718) 855-8729

Address: 265 Union Ave Brooklyn, NY 11211

Visit website

3. Roberta’s Dominos

Roberta’s is a household name in Brooklyn.

Here you will like their pizza, but one thing you should know is that you will have to wait for the pizza a little longer.

I haven’t heard of anyone who went to Roberta’s and didn’t like the pizza.

This one is situated at Domino park, south Williamsburg.

There’s something about the atmosphere around this restaurant as it provides the best ambiance to relax.

When visiting Roberta’s, try their inventively topped pizzas. You will like the crispy crust and the delicious toppings with the stretchy cheese.

261 Moore St (at Bogart St) Brooklyn, NY 11206

Visit website

4. Joe’s pizza

If you live in New York, you probably already know Joe’s name. But, when you are looking for an over-the-counter service in a cozy setting, then Joe’s is the place to visit.

Joe’s pizza has the dream to serve the Italian and New York flavors blend.

It’s available in different spots, including west Williamsburg. When visiting McCarren Park, walk a few blocks to this store and enjoy the delicious pizzas they serve.

Here, you can find pizzas that are not about too many complexities as some of the pizzas come together when using just two ingredients for toppings. Although the pizzas are simple, they are nothing short of excellent quality.

I like to visit this shop when I long for the cheese pizza and if you want to try the most authentic New York-style pizza, then go to this shop.

Phone: (718) 388-2216

Address: 216 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Visit website

5. Emmy Squared

This restaurant is set off the Brooklyn-Queens expressway. This one features the Detroit-style pizza.

We can all attest that when you eat it, you will be enjoying the creativity of the toppings.

Notice that this pizza brings along the crust that almost looks like the focaccia, thus making it unique.

This restaurant is not only about pizza rather, but you will have the best burgers here too.

Phone: (718) 360-4535

Address: 364 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Visit website

6. Rosa’s Pizza

Rosas Pizza 1


They focus on bringing the flavors of Sicilian and NY style of pizza.

It is one of the newest additions to the best pizzas in Williamsburg. Although new here, they offer some of the best pizzas making it already quite popular.

Anyone who likes the pies from this restaurant knows of the Sicilian upside-down pie because they make the best choice.

My all-time best is Sfincione pie, that’s square-shaped with a lot of tomatoes, toasted breadcrumbs, sautéed onion, and a sprinkle of pecorino.

Phone: (718) 963-2378

Address: 374 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Visit website

7. Carmine’s

Carmines 1 4



If you like to have the 5-star style of pizza, then this is what you’ll like. Whenever you’re craving the Italian style of meals, you should visit this gem.

I used to love their NY-style cheese pizza, and gladly today, you can find several different pizzas to try. If you would like the woodfired pizza, you will find the best portions.

When you like the traditional style of pizza, carmines is the place. But it’s not only about pizzas; you will even find some of the best pasta dishes.

If pizza is all you want, take their cheesesteak pizza as it will never disappoint you. Try their plain slice or deep-dish pizza if you want some more.

But I also like their bruschetta. I mean, you could never go wrong with Italian dishes.

Phone: (718) 782-9659

Address: 358 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Visit website

8. Sal’s Pizza

Sals Pizza 1


Here is another dedicated space to enjoy the pizzas.

They are known to deliver the best pizza as they only use fresh ingredients as toppings. The greatest thing then is that the pizza restaurant is at the center of Williamsburg.

Sal’s is one of the pizza joints with a name, and it has been around for more than a decade.

Phone: 718.599.7032

Address: 544 Lorimer, St. Williamsburg, NY 11211

Visit website

9. Motorino

Motorino 1


Whenever I crave the Neapolitan style of pizza, I’ve always preferred to go to Motorino. I like that you will also find the wine and beer for this meal in no time.

You know, this is also the best space to go to if you like to eat their woodfired pizza. I like the brick oven-style pizza for its rich flavors.

They offer you a wide range of options to try.

Phone: (718) 599-8899

Address: 139 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Visit website

10. Forcella

Forcella 1


When you visit Forcella, try their Montanara pizza as that will get you wowing them. Of course, you can also get other choices, but if you want the pasta dishes, you can find them here.

This site is a cocktail bar, and it also offers a New York-style pizzeria to get you enjoying the different pizzas.

Have you tried their New York fried pizza? You should choose this pizza style as it makes one of their best pizzas.

Phone: 718-388-8820

Address: 485 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Visit website

11. L’industrie

Lindustrie 1


I like pizzas made with love, and this is all about making the best pizza. This is the best place to go if you are looking for the old-world styles of pizza.

The restaurant does not have a very big space, but one thing you can be sure about is that you will like the pizza you get here.

Phone: (718) 599-0002

Address: 254 S 2nd St (Havemeyer), Brooklyn, NY

Check website

12. Tony’s pizzeria

Tonys pizzeria 1


Whenever you are looking for a slice of New York pizza, this will serve you better. But, of course, it will consistently deliver the best sandwiches too.

Also, you will like the Greek American and Italian menus they serve here.

It’s the perfect take-out that will serve the community around Williamsburg.

If you like simplicity, try their grandma’s style of pizza, where they have both marinara and pesto sauce.

Phone: (718) 384-8669

Address: 355 Graham Ave #3708, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Check website

13. Two boots Williamsburg


When you are craving the Italian Cajun style of meal, you will like this joint as they focus on such meals. The great thing you will like is that the atmosphere here is family-friendly.

One thing you will like is that they make some of the most delicious pizzas you won’t have another person making. Of all the pizzas, you will like their cornmeal crust style of pizzas.

Phone: (718) 387-2668

558 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Check website

14. MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza Company

MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza Company 1


This is located in west Williamsburg. Here you have a Neapolitan pizza company that brings you the flavors of Italy.

The greatest thing is that you will also have the local craft beer they make to serve with this pizza.

In addition, if you like the Neapolitan pizza but with a twist of the New York style of pizza, then this is it.

Expect the best calzone from this restaurant.

Phone: (718) 782-2020

Address: 174 N 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Check website

15. Aligator lounge

Aligator lounge 1


You will like this place because they deliver even the budget drinks for everyone to enjoy. The only thing you will have to do is buy craft beer. Next, you can choose your perfect pizza to enjoy with the craft beer.

The good thing is that it’s a free pizza, but it’s also a great pizza you get to enjoy.

Phone: (718) 599-4440

Address: 600 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Check website

16. Vinnie’s pizzeria

Vinnies pizzeria 1


When talking about the pizza places, you can’t just forget about this one. If you are from Williamsburg, you know this is our favorite pizza joint. For over 50 years, this restaurant has greatly served the people of Brooklyn.

You will always have a daily special that they write on the board to prepare for that day.

Phone: (718) 782-7078

Address: 148 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Check website

17. Dough vale

You will find this in central Williamsburg.

It will deliver the perfect flavors in this perfect dining room.

It will amaze you that they have the woodfired pizza, but that’s not the only food.

The good thing is that you can bring wine and beer to this restaurant to enjoy.

Of course, you will like the tarfuro pizza, but you should go out and try their different ones to find out the one you will like.

Phone: (347) 889-7400

Address: 330 S 3rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Check website

18. Leo

Leo 1


When you are looking for another place that will even serve you sourdough pizza, then this is it. I like that it’s an easy-going place where you can find your favorite pizza.

The great thing is that you will also find natural wine here, and you will enjoy the pizza along with the wine.

They also sell pasta, among other meal choices. They have other spaces where you can find the different pizza styles.

They specialize in Neapolitan woodfired pizza, and if you like the charred pizza, this will amaze you.

Other than that, I also like their pork and beef meatballs.

Phone: (718) 384-6531

Address: 123 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211


19. Patrizia’s of Williamsburg

If you are looking for the best Italian dishes, then this is what you need. This is one of the best restaurants facing the Williamsburg bridge.

It’s an authentic Neapolitan pizzeria that has been in the hands of Naples native brothers.

You will receive the award-winning flavors of Italy. Most people like them more because they have the best house-made pasta.

You will like their Margherita pizza as a fantastic appetizer.

Phone: (718) 218-9272

Address: 35 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11249


20. Screamer’s pizzeria

Screamers pizzeria 1


It will give you the hip vibe, and it always appeals to the hipster crowd.

If you are on a health spree, this will serve you best because they use all plant-based ingredients to make the best pizza in no time.

When it comes to this shop, I prefer their clean slide pizza and their New York slice with the sesame paste, and they come to serve you the best.

Phone: (347) 844-9412

Address: 620 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Check website

21. Giuseppina’s

Giuseppinas 1 2


I like that they serve the mouthwatering pies, and it’s best if you try their cheese pizza since it’s one f the most excellent choices to have.

Take a ride into this restaurant when you want to try the different specialty pizzas.

Phone: (718) 499-5052

Address: 691 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Check website

Leave a Comment