10 Best Bakeries In NYC For Cakes (Mainly In Brooklyn)

There comes a time when we all crave cakes and sugary treats. Preparing homemade cakes is very much possible because the most commonly required ingredients are flour, sugar, eggs, butter, baking soda, and a liquid.

However, sometimes preparing the cakes may not go as planned, and you may end up craving cakes done perfectly by professional chefs.

Nowadays, the preparation of cakes ranges and varies from simple to complex.

Well, New York has some of the best bakeries in the world. This is why you can readily get cakes in different forms.

New York is the best place to find delicious cakes whether you are looking for all-American cakes or French bakeries.

That said, there are several bakeries, particularly in Brooklyn, with delicious taste.

Here are some of the best places to go when you are craving cakes in NYC.

Top NYC bakeries

1. Georgetown cupcakes

Address; 111 Mercer St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Contact; +1 212-431-4504

The founders of these delicious cupcakes are sisters, and they have opened up several other branches in different parts of the country.

However, Georgetown cupcake was first opened in Washington DC.

Georgetown cupcakes are super flavorful and, at the same time, not excessively sweet. You can easily order the cakes online and get them brought directly to your location.

They do prepare different flavors of these cakes, and it all depends on what flavor you love the most.

The prices are affordable, and they can easily be customized to your liking for specific events such as birthdays. You only need to call in advance.

2. Martha’s country bakery

Address; 263 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

Contact; +1 718-486-0500

This is the best destination if you love cakes and sweets. The variety of cakes in this bakery is overwhelming, and you can never miss anything for yourself. This spot is often open until midnight.

The cakes are sold in different shapes and sizes. The cakes are top-notch with different flavors and not overly sweet.

There is a patio in the back where you can dine.

If you have never been to this place, go and try out the berry napoleon. It’s just on another level. The staff is excellent and attentive.


3. Love, Nelly

Address; 53 Rockaway Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, United States

Contact; (347) 240-6951

This is a Columbian bakery owned by two chefs who met at Crown heights. This spot might be tiny, but they have some of the best cakes in Brooklyn. The décor inside the café is beautiful, with white tiles on the floor and pink walls.

Besides cakes and delicious treats, they have meat and vegetables that they sell inside the café.

Chickpea, plantains, chicken, and empanadas are a few things you will find here sold either in whole or half a dozen.

The menu of this café is Colombian-based, and you will find treats such as cocoa laca cakes, Dulce de leche, and empanadas.

Raspa and empanadas are the most ordered by the locals.


4. Brooklyn baby cakes

Address; 506 Nostrand Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11216, United States

This cake shop was established in 2012, and the branch in Brooklyn was opened recently. The cakes and pastries in this spot are freshly made daily using the best of ingredients.

This neighborhood spot is family-owned, and the staff is friendly. They also serve breakfast, and their coffee is a must-try.

In addition, the prices of the treats are reasonable.

The coconut cake and carrot cake are some of the best treats you can try when at this cake shop.


5. Peter Pan Bakery

Address; 727 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

Contact; +1 718-389-3676

This café is always jam-packed with people of all ages who primarily come to get their donuts, cookies, and coffee which are usually well executed.

It is one of the oldest cafes in Brooklyn, and the outfits worn by the staff will show you that this café has been there for a while.

Often, you will find long lines, but the lines tend to move faster. The service is pretty fast, but there is no guarantee you will get your favorite cakes or doughnuts because of the long lines.

This spot is a cash-only café. The good news is that pretty much everything sold here is delicious, and the prices are reasonable.


6. Buttermilk bakeshop

Address; 260 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Contact; (347) 987-3941

This café was established in 2014 and features several types of treats, including cakes and ice creams.

All the cakes and ice creams are baked and prepared fresh from their open kitchen using high-quality ingredients.

They also have gluten-free products if you are vegetarian. There is a variety of cupcakes, each with unique flavors and perfectly executed.

The cakes can be customized to your liking with delicious flavors. You will not regret your time in this café.


7. Betty Bakery

Address; 448 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, United States

Contact; +1 718-246-2402

Established in 2006, Betty Bakery makes all of it’s cakes from scratch using high quality, all natural ingredients. Stop in to try their best in class carrot cake, chocolate cake or Ring Dings.

If savory is more your style, Betty Bakery has you covered as the only bakery in Brooklyn making hand held Aussie pies – they are not to be missed!


8. Cakeboi

Address; 675 Nostrand Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11216, United States

Contact; (718) 513-0595

The original location of this spot was on Throop avenue, but they have opened a new location in crown heights, still retaining their delicious cakes.

Their menu options on cakes are wide with several varieties and different flavors. They also have a variety of puddings that you can try.

The customer service is excellent, but the prices of the cakes are slightly higher than the other bakeries.

9. Café Riviera

Address; 830 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

Contact; (718) 383-8450

This is a favorite spot for the locals. It usually is jam-packed with people coming in and out of the café, especially over the weekends.

The café is tiny but with some of the best cakes in Brooklyn.

Café Riviera also serves croissants and cookies that are just as good. But, again, the portions are generous with a fair price on each product.

This café is polish-based, and many of the items prepared here are classics from Poland. This spot is worth a visit.


10. The bakery on Bergen

Address; 740 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

Contact; +1 347-627-2123

The cakes from this café are made using fresh local ingredients gotten from the markets. The staff is friendly and attentive.

Their menu is packed with a variety of cakes and cookies perfectly executed. The prices are reasonable, and everything is delectable in its unique way.

Leave a Comment