Bay Ridge in Brooklyn is an underrated foodie paradise. It is home to some of the best cuisines, including American, Italian, Irish, and Japanese cuisines.
The flavors used in the restaurants attract visitors globally to enjoy delicacies.
There is something for everyone in the neighborhood, and you are sure to create a memorable experience thanks to the great variety of dishes and drinks offered in the best Bay Ridge restaurants.
If you don’t know where to search for the best Bay Ridge restaurants, you are in luck.
This article will present the 15 best restaurants serving the best meals accommodating everyone. Stick around, and let’s get started!
1. Positano Restaurant
- 10018 4th Ave Brooklyn, NY 11209
- Phone: 718-833-1313
- Visit Website
Positano is an Italian restaurant with a focus on seafood. The restaurant will delight you from the moment you step in, from the welcoming staff to its extensive menu with great varieties.
I love trying new things, and if you are like me, you will love the experience at Positano.
The ambiance is ideal for special occasions, like anniversaries, and their cocktails are perfect pairs for their Italian cuisines.
You will love its calamari fritta and tiramisu. They are delicious! I recommend making reservations as the excellent dishes attract many people, especially on weekends.
2. Zamaan
- 8915 5th Ave Brooklyn, NY 11209
- Phone: 718-333-5476
- Visit Website
At Zamaan, you will be impressed with the delicious food and specialty drinks. It prides itself in having various dishes to accommodate every taste.
Whether you choose to dine at its beautiful outdoor seating or the elegant indoor space, the experience is wonderful.
Group meals are meant to be fun, and Zamaan is the perfect spot for group meals. You can reserve its private dining rooms for special occasions.
I loved its excellent customer service. The staff is helpful and knowledgeable about the menu items, giving guests excellent recommendations.
If you plan to visit, I recommend trying its lobster ravioli. It’s yummy and saucy. Nevertheless, feel free to try other dishes, including seafood.
3. Piccante
- 7212-A 3rd Ave Brooklyn, NY 11209
- Phone: 718-833-3919
- Visit Website
Italian dishes are ever a great choice. Piccante is worth your visit for its great homemade pasta, panini, risotto, and desserts, among other Italian options.
Its intimate atmosphere is ideal for a romantic occasion, like a date with your loved one.
The restaurant is a small hidden gem, and even if you don’t get the chance to dine in, you will have a lovely time with its deliveries. Its signature includes meat lasagna, pescatorre risotto, grilled calamari, and Rome pasta.
Its chefs have a knack for quality and freshness in their cooking. You will probably end up returning to enjoy the experience again.
4. Lombardo’s of Bay Ridge
- 279 71st St Brooklyn, NY 11209
- Phone: 718-238-7100
- Visit Website
Lombardo’s sits at the heart of Bay Ridge and is a great place for catching up with friends for its relaxed ambiance.
The portions are huge, and you will love the fresh dishes. I love pizza, and Lombardo’s has the best pizzas I have tasted so far at affordable prices.
You will regret not discovering the restaurant before after your first visit.
The place smells amazing, and the sweet aroma is a killer. Luckily, the chef goes the extra mile to guarantee satisfaction in every meal.
At Lombardo’s, you will enjoy waiter service, street parking, outdoor seating, and free wi-fi. The women-owned restaurant offers takeout and delivery.
5. Baci Ristorante
- 8424 3rd Ave Brooklyn, NY 11209
- Phone: 718-333-5879
- Visit Website
Baci Ristorante is open to all. It stands out for its excellent customer service. The staff is welcoming, and you will experience the away from home feeling.
It has a talented chef who utilizes fresh and locally sourced ingredients in its cooking.
Furthermore, it has a full bar with many refreshments to match everyone’s preferences.
If you want to enjoy a family dining experience, Baci Ristorante got your back.
The delicious food will make you return. You can’t go wrong with its menu.
6. Gino’s Restaurant
- 7414 Fifth Avenue,Brooklyn, NY 11209
- Phone: 718-748-1698
- Visit Website
Gino’s is an amazing Italian restaurant, and everyone loves its pizza. The restaurant has existed since 1964, and the quality of its dishes has kept getting better.
The dining experience is superb, especially if you pair your meal with a tasty drink from its bar.
The family-owned restaurant is a local’s staple for authentic Italian dishes, and I recommend trying its appetizers, including the seafood salad and entrees like veal medallions.
Gino’s is a great choice for lunch, dinner, and late at night. The good thing is that it accepts many payment methods, such as credit cards, visas, Mastercard, American Express, and discover.
The place can easily flock, and making a reservation is the best choice.
7. Skinflints
- 7902 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-4002
- Phone: 718-745-1116
- Visit Website
A restaurant featuring a bar and pub is an attraction. It guarantees that you can pair its meals with a tasty drink.
I enjoyed visiting Skinflints for its American cuisines alongside a pub and bar. Burgers are my favorite, and Skinflints never misses in creating delicious burgers.
The restaurant has an extensive menu of delicious American dishes.
The ambiance is great, the staff is friendly, and I loved how they offer affordable prices, yet the quality of their food is top-notch.
Its interior is beautiful, and the vintage look is fantastic alongside the tile floors, stained glass, and brick walls.
You can’t help but love the beauty. The bar will welcome you once you enter, and it has two dining rooms.
8. Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria
- 7305 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-2405
- Phone: 718-745-0222
- Visit Website
Pizza satisfies any Italian craving, and Vesuvio has mastered the art of making mouthwatering pizzas.
The sweet aroma will lure you in, and the welcoming staff will get you seated quickly, and you will love the pizza and Italian dishes offered.
Its homemade pasta and sauce are amazing. I love the pasta chicken parmigiana.
There is something in it that makes it so delicious.
The restaurant has a kid’s menu, so you have no worries tagging your kids along.
The seating is classic if you choose to dine in. Moreover, it offers takeout, and you won’t be disappointed with the delivery.
9. Taj Mahal Indian Restaurant
- 7315 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-2470
- Phone: 718-836-1512
- Visit Website
Taj Mahal will sort you out whether you are craving fish curry, combos, aloo gobi, crisp papadum, or any other Indian dish.
It has the best Indian cuisine and beverages. You have no reason not to love the place. The food is delicious, prices are fair, and services are excellent.
Additionally, its menu incorporates vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options.
The tables are set outside during summer, and my main takeaway was how the menu allows you to try new things every time you visit.
Taj Mahal offers takeout and delivery. Its use of locally sourced ingredients in its cooking earns it a spot among the best Bay Ridge restaurants you must visit for the best dining experience.
10. Greenhouse Café
- 7717 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-3001
- Phone: 718-833-8200
- Visit Website
View this post on Instagram
For a special or private experience, I recommend reserving a private dining space at Greenhouse Café.
Table service and seating are also available. The American restaurant retains guests through its live music and exceptional cooking.
Moreover, drinks are plenty from its bar and pub. What more could you ask? The restaurant is old-school, but the services are exemplary, and the food is just amazing!
This local staple restaurant has a lovely ambiance, and the relaxed atmosphere is attractive for a quiet evening and romantic for a date night.
Their services are great, and the staff is helpful with the menu. It opens daily from 11:30 AM to around 11:00 PM.
11. Yemen Café
- 7317 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, United States
- Phone: 718-834-9533
- Visit Website
You will come across Yemen Café if you stroll along 5th Avenue. The American restaurant and takeout café will delight you with classic dishes like Fatah and Salta.
The place stands out for its Yemen dishes that give one a warm and cozy feeling.
Yemen Café has served patrons an exotic home flavor since 1986, and its welcoming atmosphere and interactive staff guarantee satisfaction to all.
The authentic dishes slap differently, and on a cool day, I recommend taking its soup and bread as appetizers.
Still, the menu has a great variety of goodies, and even the choosiest foodie can’t lack a delicacy of choice.
12. Bay Ridge Pizzeria
- 7704 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-3312
- Phone: 718-680-5405
- Visit Website
The Italian restaurant offers a lot, but my favorite items are Caesar salad, pasta, sausage parmigiana, and pepperoni puffs, not forgetting its tasty pizza.
The pizzeria is loved for the great atmosphere surrounding it, and the experience feels like the early ’70s.
The place is such a vibe, from how clean it is to the friendly staff who warmly welcome you to the restaurant and quickly work to serve your order.
They offer the best thin crust pizza around, and you will agree with me once you take your first bite.
Its outdoor seating has a scenic view, and it is the best spot to enjoy its delicious dishes paired with tasty wine or beer.
13. Salty Dog Restaurant
- 7509 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-3103
- Phone: 718-238-0030
- Visit Website
When in Bay Ridge and looking for a place to dine and catch up with friends, don’t shy about visiting Salty Dog Restaurant.
Here, you will enjoy great dishes and drinks from its bar and pub. The place is warm and accommodating to all.
I love how its menu offers plenty of delightful options and quality dishes served in huge portions.
Salty Dog restaurant satisfies all American cravings, and you will leave the place full and with a smile for its excellent services.
Additionally, the fair prices for the meals ensure you eat to your fill without breaking the bank.
I wouldn’t suggest you leave the neighborhood without visiting the cozy restaurant.
14. Schnitzel Haus
- 7319 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-2603
- Phone: 718-836-5600
- Visit Website
The restaurant is my favorite spot for German and European cuisines, and a pub and bar.
Fred and Amber have served locals of Bay Ridge with authentic dishes for lunch and dinner daily. It also offers outside catering services for events.
Additionally, you will enjoy great live music to spice your dining experience.
The experience is wonderful, and you will love the table service and takeout services.
I recommend visiting on Thursdays to enjoy its prime rib specials. Also, try its fried veal with German steak fries.
The place opens every 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM Monday to Wednesday and every 12:00 PM to 11:00 PM on Friday to Sunday.
15. Something Greek
- 7616 3rd Ave Ste A, Brooklyn, NY 11209-3145
- Phone: 718-748-8200
- Visit Website
Something Greek opens from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. The restaurant serves Greek and Mediterranean cuisines plus table service, takeout, and delivery.
The freshness of their dishes is on another level, and it is my go-to place for excellent salads and dishes.
Its daily specials are my favorite, and the atmosphere is ever great for any occasion.
On Tuesday, you will enjoy its chicken thighs, and on Saturday, you will love the stuffed pepper and tomato alongside lemon potatoes and salad.
You don’t need to go to Greek to enjoy Greek food. The restaurant brings the Greek feeling right to you. You will love it!
Final Thoughts
Bay Ridge restaurants offer great options for everyone. You can’t lack your favorites from the many restaurants covered in this article. Whether you crave Italian, Asian, American, or any other cuisine, you have a match.
Going through each of the restaurants in the neighborhood can be a challenge. Instead, I recommended visiting any of the above restaurants for the best dining experience.
If you feel we’ve left any great Bay Ridge restaurants out, feel free to share your thoughts or suggestions and leave a comment below, and I will gladly check it out!
These are really nice restaurants. Thanks for sharing